
Why ESG Ratings from Different Providers Disagree
Credit ratings from different agencies usually agree. ESG ratings often do not. The reasons are built into how ESG ratings are made, and they change how investors should use them.
81 pages carry this tag.

Credit ratings from different agencies usually agree. ESG ratings often do not. The reasons are built into how ESG ratings are made, and they change how investors should use them.

Of the three letters in ESG, governance has the clearest link to investor losses. Most large Indian corporate failures began as governance problems before they became financial ones.

Most people start with the share price and the P/E. A better order starts with the business, works through the statements, and looks at the price last.

Accounting problems rarely show up as one dramatic number. They show up as small places where the statements stop agreeing with each other. Here are five to check first.

"Debt-free" is one of the most reassuring phrases in an investor presentation. Sometimes it signals strength. Sometimes it hides idle cash, disguised borrowing, or a business no lender will touch.

India's BRSR reports run to dozens of pages. This opinion piece argues that most of it is narrative, and points to the small part that investors should actually read.
The laws, regulators and codes that decide how Indian listed companies are run, how the rules grew after each scandal, and the main conflict that Indian governance is built to manage.
The rules on board size, independence and meetings, the five main board committees, and how to read a board's real structure from the annual report.
The legal test for independence, the rules on tenure, appointment and resignation, and an eight-point checklist for judging whether a board's independent directors are really independent.
The signals in promoter holding, the mechanics of share pledging, the SEBI disclosure rules, and the red flags that point to forced selling or a change in control.
How related-party deals are defined and approved, SEBI's new turnover-based thresholds, a five-step method for reading the related-party note, and the red flags that point to value leakage.
Qualified opinions, emphasis of matter paragraphs and mid-term auditor exits are among the earliest public warnings of trouble. The opinion types, SEBI's resignation rules, and a red flag checklist.
The legal limits on managerial pay in India, the special votes needed for high promoter pay, how ESOPs work and dilute, and how to judge whether pay is linked to performance.
The rights that minority shareholders have in India, which decisions need a special vote, how e-voting results reveal what investors think, and the role of proxy advisors.
Stewardship codes ask mutual funds, insurers and pension funds to act as responsible owners of the companies they invest in. SEBI's six principles, the other Indian codes, and how to read a fund's voting record.
India is one of the few countries that makes companies spend on CSR by law. Who must spend, how much, on what, what happens to unspent money, and how analysts should read CSR disclosures.
The rules on bribery, whistleblowing, insider trading and material event disclosure that shape corporate integrity in India, and the signals analysts can find in filings.
Accidents, protests, regulatory action and fraud allegations can hit a company far faster than any rating changes. How controversy scores work, four Indian examples, the gap between allegations and findings, and a simple way to build event risk into a valuation.
The three tools investors have for changing company behaviour: talking, voting and selling. The research on which ones work, collaborative engagement through Climate Action 100+, the retreat of the net zero alliances since 2025, and Indian examples.
Promoter holding is the percentage of a company's shares owned by its founders or controlling group. Read with institutional holdings, its trend is an early warning of trouble long before it shows in the accounts.
Compare the ratio with the legal minimum that applies to the company. If the chair is a non-executive director with no promoter link, at least...
Also calculate pledged shares as a percentage of total share capital. SEBI requires detailed reasons when combined encumbrance reaches 50% of promoter...
The legal minimum is 2%. A figure below 2% is not automatically a breach if the gap relates to ongoing projects and has been moved to the Unspent CSR...
There is no fixed safe level, because some business models depend on group trade. The useful tests are the trend (RPT intensity rising faster than...
Ten situations from the annual reports and exchange filings of hypothetical Indian listed companies. For each one, decide whether it is a red flag, worth a closer look, or normal practice.
The person or group that controls a company, usually its founder, a business group, a parent company or the government.
Any deal between a company and a related party, such as its promoters, directors, key managers, their relatives or the entities they control.
A non-executive director with no material relationship with the company, its promoters or its management that could affect their judgement.
The percentage of a company's shares owned by its promoter and promoter group: the founders, controlling family or parent company, and the people and entities connected to them.
The system by which companies are directed and controlled, including who makes decisions, who checks them and how shareholders are protected.
The promoter together with close relatives and the companies, firms and trusts the promoter controls.
Shares that a promoter has given to a lender as collateral for a loan, usually a loan taken by the promoter or a promoter group company rather than by the listed company itself.
Any arrangement that restricts a shareholder's freedom to sell shares or gives someone else a claim over them.
A promise by a shareholder to a lender not to sell or pledge certain shares while a loan is outstanding.
The rule that listed companies must keep at least 25% of their shares with the public.
Shares that carry more votes per share than ordinary shares, allowed for some founder-led technology companies.
The share of a board made up of independent directors, and more broadly the board's ability to act separately from management and the promoter.
A senior independent director who leads the other independent directors, especially when the chair is not independent.
The board committee that oversees financial reporting, auditors, internal controls and related-party deals.
The board committee that oversees appointments to the board and senior management, succession and pay policy.
The board committee that handles complaints and service issues of shareholders and other security holders.
The board committee that oversees the company's risk framework, required for the top 1,000 listed companies.
The board committee that sets and monitors a company's corporate social responsibility policy and spending.
A related-party transaction large enough to need shareholder approval under SEBI's rules.
A single advance approval for a set of repeated related-party transactions, within stated limits, instead of approving each one separately.
A deal made on the same terms that two unrelated parties would agree to in the open market.
A "clean" audit opinion stating that the financial statements give a true and fair view.
An audit opinion stating that the accounts are fair "except for" specific items that are wrong or could not be verified.
An audit opinion stating that the financial statements as a whole are materially misstated and do not give a true and fair view.
An audit report in which the auditor declines to give any opinion because it could not collect enough evidence.
A paragraph in an audit report that draws attention to an important matter already disclosed in the accounts, without changing the opinion.
An area that the auditor judged most significant in the audit, described in the audit report of listed companies.
A government order that requires auditors to report on specific matters, such as loans to related parties, defaults and frauds, in an annexure to the audit report.
The policies and procedures a company uses to make sure its financial reporting is reliable and its assets are protected.
The rule that limits how long the same auditor can audit a company.
The senior officers named by law as responsible for running a company: the CEO or managing director, whole-time directors, the company secretary and the CFO.
A scheme that gives employees the right to buy company shares at a set price after a waiting period.
A firm that analyses shareholder resolutions and recommends how institutional investors should vote.
A set of principles asking institutional investors to act as responsible owners of the companies they invest in.
Shareholders using their rights to push a company to change its strategy, governance or management.
Electronic voting by shareholders on company resolutions, mandatory for listed companies in India.
A company's formal whistleblower system, through which directors and employees can report genuine concerns.
Trading in a company's shares while holding unpublished price sensitive information about it.
Information about a company that is not yet public and would likely move its share price if it were.
The period during which a company's designated persons are allowed to trade in its shares.
A listed company's duty to tell the stock exchanges promptly about events that could affect its share price or investors' decisions.
A company's spending on social and environmental causes outside its core business; in India, a legal requirement for larger companies.
A special bank account into which a company must move CSR money allocated to ongoing projects but not yet spent.
The list in the Companies Act of activities on which companies can spend their CSR money, and the funds to which unspent amounts can go.
A letter in which a company reassures a lender about another entity's ability or intention to repay a loan.
A borrower that does not repay a bank loan despite being able to, or that diverts or siphons off the borrowed money.
Dialogue between investors and company management or boards to improve ESG practices, disclosure or performance.
Voting on shareholder resolutions, usually by an institution on behalf of its clients, without attending the meeting in person.
Related topics: Valuation, DCF, Relative valuation, Cost of capital, Financial statements, Cash flow, Earnings quality, Red flags